Log in

25 April 2013 @ 06:59 pm
yay! we're here!  
Thanks to everyone for voting! :) We have our winners!

Banner-maker this week is mark_pierre.


beeej with -5


rochvelleth with -1


mark_pierre with 0

( - ) = a favorite or 'positive' vote
(+ comment) = a comment not counting towards your score.
If your icon number only has a zero, you received no votes.
A lower number is a better score.

1. -1 (+comment)
2. -5 (+comment)
3. 0 (+comment)

Comment with your icon number to get your votes. Let me know if you'd like my reply screened or unscreened. (I default to unscreened.)
rochvelleth: SW Hanrochvelleth on April 26th, 2013 05:56 am (UTC)
Oh goodness, second place! WOO! Congratulations to beeej, and mark_pierre too, those were beautiful icons!

Comments for 1 please, unscreened is fine.
oba: x-men - she smilesobaona on April 28th, 2013 07:22 am (UTC)
Congrats on second place!

- 1 (Nice cropping, great color.)

(+comment: - I feel like there's a theme here! The red of the planet to the red of Maul's eyes, to Leia's lips. Interesting cropping on all of them, though I think Maul's is the most successful (the almost there crop of Leia's nose strikes me as awkward) - but I really love these, no doubt about that!)
rochvelleth: SW Hanrochvelleth on May 9th, 2013 06:22 am (UTC)
Thank you!!
Gwinna: Anakin/Padme - RotSgwinna487 on April 28th, 2013 07:50 pm (UTC)
Congratulations, everyone! Sorry I didn't get a chance to vote (had a rough week irl), but your icons were all really amazing!
Becky: Bradley footiebeeej on April 30th, 2013 02:46 am (UTC)
Holy cats! I am gobsmacked! Thank you to everyone who voted, and congrats to rochvelleth an mark_pierre!

Can I have comments for #2, please? Thank you!
oba: fringe - olivia (smile)obaona on May 1st, 2013 03:38 am (UTC)

- There isn't a weak icon in this set. It's very creative in terms of composition, the colours are gorgeous and it's struck the perfect balance between sharp and blurry. Congrats!
- The coloring in this set pops, and the cut outs & texture use are well done. I think the third icon is particularly striking, especially because of the subtle coloring and crop.
- I rather like the composition and the soft colors of all three of these.
- The vibrant coloring on the 1st one is very nice and the coloring in general is great on the second one, very natural looking. Love the crop on the 3rd one.
- Icon #1: beautiful colouring. Icon #2: great cropping and use of texture. Icon #3: lovely cropping and colouring.

(+comment: - Such beautiful coloring! I love your first icon best - the purple and blue are striking and very pretty, which is not easy to do with an icon of a ship! I also love the Obi-Wan one for it's natural coloring, and Leia looks so dreamy here. Very nice crop, too.)
Absent-minded dragon: leia.maskmark_pierre on May 8th, 2013 10:58 pm (UTC)
Whoa! How did I miss this post?
Congratulations to beeej and rochvelleth! :D

I'd like my comment for set #3, pretty please. :)
oba: sanctuary - helen magnusobaona on May 14th, 2013 12:38 am (UTC)
Congrats on third place!

- You excel in cropping, imho. I LOVE the Leia/Alderaan blend, it's so creative and something I actually haven't seen done before (though it makes so much sense!). I also love the cropping on Anakin, how it brings your eye to his eyes and his braid (which are his distinct features, really). Lovely set!